Compare

Choosing the Best Motorized Patio Screen: MagnaTrack vs V-Track

Six screen options, two track systems, one decision. This page lays out exactly what separates them — mechanism, span, fabric, ratings, and what each one is actually best at — so you can arrive at your consultation knowing what you want.

Every screen is custom, so the cost depends on the opening size, fabric, motor and installation details. Quotes are free, and we give you a firm number after measuring. For typical installed ranges by system, see our motorized screen cost guide. Request a free quote or read our frequently asked questions.

Progressive Screens

MagnaTrack

Dual opposing-polarity rare-earth magnets hold the screen edge in the track continuously and pull it back in if it is pushed out — the system self-corrects.

Max size	30 ft W × 20 ft H
Wind	75 mph standard · 157+ mph certified (Defender)
Spans	Single opening to 30 ft
Warranty	Lifetime aluminum · 15-yr screens · 5-yr motors · 2-yr remotes
Patents	US 11,421,474 · US 9,719,292
Best for	Homeowners who want the screen to fix itself, and anyone who needs a certified storm-rated option.

Explore MagnaTrack

Keder Screens

V-Track

A thermoplastic keder bead welded to the fabric edge rides inside an aluminum V-channel. Wind pressure drives the bead deeper into the channel, so the hold tightens as the wind rises.

Max size	Spans to ~99 ft with RAD
Wind	100+ mph (manufacturer internal testing; not a storm rating)
Spans	Single span to ~99 ft, no center posts
Warranty	Component terms confirmed per project (fabrics carry a 10-year performance warranty)
Patents	V-Screen Retention System · Kontour Guide (patent pending)
Best for	Very wide openings where a center post would ruin the view, and weather enclosures.

Explore V-Track

Feature by feature

The full comparison

Feature	MagnaTrack	V-Track	What it means for you
Retention method	Magnetic — self-correcting along the full track	Mechanical keder bead in a V-channel	Both eliminate the zippers and cables that wear out on cheaper systems.
Maximum single opening	30 ft wide × 20 ft tall	~99 ft wide with RAD roller reinforcement	Beyond 30 ft, V-Track is the only option that avoids a center post.
Recovers from a blow-out	Yes — magnets reseat the screen automatically	No — but the keder cannot leave the channel under normal load	Different answers to the same problem: MagnaTrack forgives, V-Track prevents.
Certified storm rating	Defender: 157+ mph, ±200 PSF, FL30798, Miami-Dade	None — wind-capable, retract in severe weather	Only MagnaTrack offers a third-party-certified storm product.
Solar mesh (UV blocked)	70–97% (Textilene 80/90, 95, 95 Nano, 97 Nano)	Up to 97% (VisionTex, Twitchell, Serge Ferrari)	Comparable performance; the openness factor you choose matters more than the brand.
Insect mesh	16/14 and 17/20 stainless, incl. no-see-um	18×16 standard, 20×30 no-see-um, pet-resistant	V-Track adds a pet-resistant weave; both offer no-see-um.
Vinyl / weather enclosure	Clear and tinted vinyl (commercial line)	Clear · tinted smoke · heavy-duty · restaurant grade	V-Track tiers vinyl for commercial duty cycles.
Uneven floors	Up to 4 in of bias accommodated	Channel tolerance handles typical variation	MagnaTrack publishes a specific tolerance, which matters on older patios.
Motors	Gaposa · Sense · SHSM high-speed (90 RPM)	Somfy · Alfa	All support obstacle detection; SHSM is the fastest we install.
Smart home	Control4, ELAN, RTI, URC, Savant, Crestron, Lutron, Alexa, Google, SmartThings, Josh.ai	Somfy myLink → Alexa, Google Home; wind/rain sensors	MagnaTrack has the broader integration list for whole-home systems.
Frame finishes	White, Ivory, Beige, Silver Pearl, Bronze, Night Sky, Dark Gray, custom RAL	Black, Bronze, Tan, White, custom RAL	Both offer custom RAL color matching at additional cost and lead time.
Published warranty	Lifetime aluminum · 15 yr screens · 5 yr motors · 2 yr remotes	Not published by the manufacturer; confirmed per project	We will put the exact V-Track terms in writing on your quote.

Wind figures are not equivalent claims: MagnaTrack Defender carries third-party certification (FL30798, Miami-Dade, ASTM/TAS testing); V-Track's 100+ mph figure is the manufacturer's own internal testing and is not a storm rating. Retract any screen in severe weather unless it is a certified storm product.

Start from your problem

Which one is right for you?

"My opening is wider than 30 feet and I do not want a post."

V-Track with RAD

"I want the strongest storm and debris protection available."

MagnaTrack Defender

"Afternoon sun makes my patio unusable."

Solar mesh on either system

"Mosquitoes and no-see-ums end our evenings."

Insect mesh, 20×30 weave

"I want to use the space in wind and rain."

Vinyl enclosure panels

"Kids, pets, and patio furniture knock things around."

MagnaTrack — it resets itself

"It is a restaurant, club, or HOA amenity space."

MagnaTrack Commercial or V-Track vinyl

"I want it in a whole-home automation system."

MagnaTrack — widest integration list

All six options

Every screen we install

MagnaTrack Residential Screens

Insect, solar, and vinyl screens for patios, lanais, garages, and windows — on the self-correcting MagnaTrack system.

Details

MagnaTrack Defender Storm Screens

Our strongest screen — DuPont Kevlar OmegaTex Defender fabric engineered to hurricane-grade standards, for severe-wind and storm-debris protection on exposed properties.

Details